Quick answer
Replace when the unit is past about 15 years for a furnace or 12 to 15 for an AC, when one repair costs a large share of a new system, or when repairs keep coming. Otherwise a repair usually makes sense.
Start with the $5,000 rule
Multiply the age of the equipment by the price of the repair.
- Under $5,000: repairing is usually the better value.
- Over $5,000: get a replacement price and compare before you decide.
For example, a 12-year-old furnace with a $450 repair comes to $5,400. That doesn't mean you must replace it. It means the replacement price deserves a look.
When repair is the clear choice
If the system is under about 10 years old and the problem is a single worn part, repair it. Common examples:
- Igniter or flame sensor on a furnace
- Capacitor or contactor on an AC
- Blower motor
- Clogged condensate drain or a tripped safety switch
- Thermostat problems
When replacement makes more sense
- Cracked heat exchanger. It can leak carbon monoxide, and on an older furnace the repair rarely makes sense.
- Failed compressor on an older AC. The compressor is the most expensive part of the system.
- An old AC that uses R-22 refrigerant. R-22 is no longer produced in the U.S., so recharging a leaking system gets more expensive every year.
- Repeated breakdowns. Two or three repairs in a couple of seasons usually means more are coming.
- High bills and uneven comfort. A new, properly sized system can fix both.
Replacing just the AC or just the furnace
Air conditioners and furnaces share the blower and ductwork, and the AC's indoor coil sits on top of the furnace. Newer AC systems also use different refrigerants than older ones, so a new outdoor unit usually needs a matching new indoor coil. If both pieces are close in age, replacing them together often costs less than two separate jobs a few years apart.
It's also the right time to consider a heat pump, which handles cooling and much of the heating in one system.
How we price it
When a system could go either way, we write up the repair price and the replacement price side by side, along with the age and condition of what you have. You choose. Financing is available on replacements.
